Password reminder
Cardiovascular News
Contact the editor Visit Cardiovascular News Twitter feed Visit Cardiovascular News Facebook page

ESC sets consensus over TAVI

Friday, 02 Sep 2011 12:33


The annual meeting of the European Society of Cardiology, in Paris, has enhanced the status of TAVI as the “gold standard” for inoperable patients suffering from severe aortic stenosis. However, concerns about high rates of permanent pacemaker implantation after TAVI remain, specialists say. 

TAVI was introduced nearly 10 years ago as an alternative procedure with limited application but it has expanded significantly in the course of recent years. Despite its increasing popularity among physicians, however, haemodynamic performance and valve durability remain unknown.

Now, for the first time, data from 393 consecutive patients undergoing implantation of a CoreValve self-expandable prosthesis at the German Heart Centre in Munich, Germany, have been presented: they show a “sustained improvement of haemodynamic values” and no signs of early or “unexpected” deterioration of the valve at three-year of follow-up.


“We all know that any biological valve gets deteriorated after a certain period of time, would this be 10 or 12 years. We know exactly when this will occur to a traditional heart valve, but we do not know when this will occur to a transcatheter valve. Now we know that after three years the haemodynamic performance of transcatheter valves is unchanged,” Anke Optiz, co-investigator of the study, told Cardiovascular News.


Based on the societies guidelines, so far most of the TAVI registries have included patients with high logistic Euroscore (20% or higher). However data presented at ESC this year suggest that 100% procedural success is possible even in a patient population with lower logistic Euroscore. The prospective, single-centre data refer to a cohort of 177 patients who underwent implantation with the Edwards valve at the Rouen University Hospital, France, between May 2006 and January 2011.


“We examined the population with lower logistic Euroscore because we were under the impression that these patients reacted better to TAVI as they were younger and had fewer comorbidities,” said Matthieu Godin, co-investigator of the study. “The retrospective analysis showed absence of death at 30 days for this specific group of low-risk patients. This result was beyond our expectations,” he added. Despite this data, Godin noted, “we should never forget that conventional surgery remains the gold standard for the lower-risk patient population”.


The Rouen experience is not isolated. An increasing trend to include lower risk patients into TAVI registries has been observed across European countries in the last few years. But according to both cardiology and cardiac surgery specialists discussing TAVI at ESC, this should not become standard practice.


“We can say that TAVI is doing relatively well – better than conventional surgery – within a certain high-risk group. But it is difficult to say that TAVI will necessarily do better in the lower group as well, because we do not have evidence of better results with TAVI compared to conventional surgery in any trial, including the US PARTNER trial where TAVI results are extremely good,” Olaf Wendler, clinical director, Cardiothoracic Surgery, King’s College Hospital, London, UK, told Cardiovascular News. “That is why I think TAVI should focus on patients who would clearly benefit from this new treatment immediately.”

Add New Comment

Related Items

Most popular

Long-term results of RESPECT indicate that PFO closure may be effective at preventing recurrent stroke
Friday, 16 Oct 2015
The long-term study results from the RESPECT trial found that closing a patent foramen ovale (PFO) with an Amplatzer PFO Occluder was superior to medical management in the prevention of recurrent ... Long-term results of RESPECT indicate that PFO closure may be effective at preventing recurrent stroke

Custom-designed vascular training model now available at events
Thursday, 05 Nov 2015
The ThinkRadial Vascular Training Model provides realistic simulation to several procedurally critical vascular destinations, while allowing the practitioner to “see” the way radial products perform ... Custom-designed vascular training model now available at events

Friday, 16 Oct 2015
Edwards Lifesciences has announced a one-year survival rate of 89.3% for high-risk patients who received the Edwards Sapien 3 transcatheter aortic valve via transfemoral, as well as low rates of ... Edwards Sapien 3 valve demonstrates high survival and low stroke rate at one year


Helping Little Hearts to mend
Friday, 27 Nov 2015
Nurun Nahar Fatema talks about how Muntada Aid’s Little Hearts campaign has helped children in Bangladesh with congenital heart problems. Helping Little Hearts to mend

An interventional cardiologist’s view on left atrial appendage closure
Thursday, 12 Nov 2015
Martin W Bergmann is an interventional cardiologist working in Germany, who performs percutaneous LAA closure procedures. He explores why there is still a need for such procedures even in the era of ... An interventional cardiologist’s view on left atrial appendage closure


Corrado Tamburino
Tuesday, 20 Oct 2015
Corrado Tamburino (full professor of Cardiology, Ferrarotto & Policlinico Hospitals, University of C... Corrado Tamburino

Javier Escaned
Wednesday, 02 Sep 2015
Javier Escaned (head of Section, Interventional Cardiology Unit, Hospital Clinico San Carlos, M... Javier Escaned

Cardiac Rhythm News Vascular News Cardiovascular News Interventional News Spinal News NeuroNews
BIBA Medical BIBA MedTech Insights CX Symposium ilegx
Password Reminder

BIBA Medical, 526 Fulham Road, Fulham, London, SW6 5NR.
TEL: +44 (0)20 7736 8788 FAX: +44 (0)20 7736 8283 EMAIL: 
© BIBA Medical Ltd is a company registered in England and Wales with company number 2944429.
VAT registration number 730 6811 50.
Site Map | Terms and Conditions